The short answer
- Formula: MAO = after-repair value × your percentage − repairs − closing and holding costs − your fee.
- The 70% rule is a rule of thumb, not a law or a standard. It bundles profit and most costs into one number.
- After-repair value comes from comps: at least three closed sales of similar properties, close by, usually within the last 12 months.
- Count what the shortcut hides: back taxes and penalties, holding months, both sides' closing costs, and an honest repair number.
- Write the math down on the deal, so the offer can be checked, explained to the seller and learned from later.
The formula, one piece at a time
- After-repair value (ARV): what the property should sell for once it is fixed up, or, for land, in the condition a buyer expects.
- Your percentage: the share of ARV you are willing to pay before repairs and costs. 70% is the classic number for house flips. Many buyers use a different one for their market and their risk.
- Repairs: a line-by-line estimate, not a guess per square foot, once you have seen the property.
- Closing and holding costs: title, recording, loan costs, taxes, insurance, utilities and interest for the months you will hold it.
- Your fee: for a wholesaler, the assignment fee you need; for a flipper, the profit you require on top of the percentage.
Put together: MAO = ARV × percentage − repairs − closing and holding costs − fee. If you use 70% as the percentage, some of your costs and profit are already inside the 30% you left out, so be careful not to count them twice, or to forget the ones the 30% does not really cover.
A worked example (made-up round numbers)
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| After-repair value from three comps | $200,000 |
| × 70% | $140,000 |
| − Repairs (line by line) | − $35,000 |
| − Closing and holding costs not covered by the 30% | − $6,000 |
| − Assignment fee | − $10,000 |
| Maximum allowable offer | $89,000 |
The numbers are for illustration only. Your opening offer is usually below the MAO, so there is room to meet the seller without going over it.
Getting ARV right: pick comps the way appraisers must
The MAO is only as good as the ARV, and the ARV is only as good as the comparable sales behind it. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, which sets the rules appraisers follow for the loans it buys, is a useful yardstick even when no lender is involved:
- At least three. "A minimum of three closed comparables must be reported in the sales comparison approach."
- Recent. "Comparable sales that have closed within the last 12 months should be used", though the guide adds that "the best and most appropriate comparable sales may not always be the most recent sales."
- Similar. "Comparable sales should have similar physical and legal characteristics when compared to the subject property."
- Close by. "Sale activity from within the neighborhood is the best indicator of value."
- Adjust by what the market pays, with proof. Adjustments "must reflect the market's reaction" to the differences, and the report "must, at a minimum, summarize the supporting evidence."
Closed sales only: a listing price is what someone hopes for. Prefer price per square foot for houses of similar size, and price per acre for land, and throw out a sale that was clearly not at arm's length, such as a family transfer.
Costs the 70% rule leaves out
Back taxes, penalties and interest
Distressed properties often come with unpaid taxes, and the bill grows every month. In Texas, the Comptroller explains that "a tax lien automatically attaches to property on Jan. 1 each year to secure payment of all taxes"; taxes unpaid on February 1 are delinquent, and the collector adds "a six percent penalty and one percent interest". On July 1, "the penalty becomes 12 percent", and private attorneys who collect delinquent accounts can add "up to 20 percent to cover their fees". Get the payoff from the tax office for your expected closing date and subtract it.
Holding time
Every month between closing and resale costs taxes, insurance, utilities and, if you borrowed, interest. Estimate the months honestly, including the time to find a contractor and the time to sell, and multiply.
Both closings
A flip pays closing costs twice: when you buy and when you sell, including the commission if an agent sells it. A wholesale assignment has its own costs, and a double close has two.
The repair estimate you have not seen yet
Before a walkthrough, use a range, and offer from the high end of the range. Replace it with a line-by-line estimate once you have seen the property.
Land changes the math
Vacant land has no repair line, but it has its own deductions: survey, clearing, access, back taxes, and a much longer time to sell in many markets. Land is usually priced per acre from closed land sales of similar size and use in the same county. Our guide to pipeline stages for land deals shows which checks belong before the offer, and the land investor CRM guide lists the fields that set the price.
Try your own numbers in the free offer calculator; it runs in your browser and shows the math.
Write it down on the deal
An offer number with no math behind it cannot be checked by a partner, explained to a seller, or improved next month. Save the comps, the repair lines, the costs, the percentage and the fee on the deal itself. When a deal is lost, the saved math tells you whether you were too low or the seller was never going to sell. When you win, it tells your buyer why the price is fair. Add the next step from the follow-up schedule so the offer is chased.
How this fits in NuVentrec today
NuVentrec's deal analyzer saves comps, repairs, closing costs, your percentage and your fee on each deal, works ARV out by price per square foot, price per acre or the average of the comps, and prints an offer sheet. You can enter your own ARV instead of the comps' figure, and the math stays with the deal. See what each plan includes on the pricing page, or estimate what slow follow-up costs you with the lost leads calculator.
Questions people ask
What is the 70% rule in real estate?
A rule of thumb for house flips: pay no more than 70% of the after-repair value, minus the repairs. It is a quick screen, not a law or a standard, and it hides costs that vary a lot between deals.
How do I calculate maximum allowable offer?
MAO = after-repair value × your percentage − repairs − closing and holding costs not covered by the percentage − your fee. Start from at least three recent closed comparable sales.
Is 70% right for every market?
No. In markets with high prices and fast sales, buyers often pay a higher share; where sales are slow or repairs are uncertain, a lower one. Base yours on your costs and the profit you need.
How many comps do I need for ARV?
At least three closed sales of similar properties nearby. Fannie Mae's appraisal rules require a minimum of three closed comparables and prefer sales from the last 12 months.
Does the 70% rule work for land?
Land has no repair line, so most land buyers price per acre from closed land sales and subtract back taxes, survey and access costs. The percentage they pay depends on how long the land takes to sell.