The short answer
- The best-known study found a steep drop inside the first half hour. In the Lead Response Management study, the odds of reaching a web lead by phone were 100 times lower at 30 minutes than at 5 minutes, and the odds of qualifying the lead were 21 times lower.
- Most businesses are nowhere near that. A 2014 test of 9,538 companies found that only 22% called a web lead back at all.
- The numbers come from a software vendor's research, so treat the exact multiples with care. The direction is not in doubt: sooner is better, and the gap is large.
- You do not need a call center. You need an alert that reaches a person, a named owner for each lead, a short first script, and a plan for nights and weekends.
- Fast does not mean careless. Do-not-call and consent rules apply to the first call and the first text as much as the tenth.
What the five-minute study measured
The figure most people quote comes from the Lead Response Management study, presented by Dave Elkington of InsideSales.com and James Oldroyd, then at MIT's Sloan School of Management. The copy we read is dated 2008. The study looked at leads that came in through web forms and at the calls made to them, and it used plain definitions: a contact is a call that reaches a live person, and a lead is qualified when the person agrees to enter the sales process, for example by setting an appointment.
The researchers first cut the data by the hour and then cut the first three hours into five-minute pieces. Their findings on response time:
- The odds of contacting a lead fell by more than 10 times over the first hour, and the odds of qualifying it by more than 6 times.
- From 5 minutes to 30 minutes the odds of contact fell 100 times and the odds of qualifying fell 21 times.
- Even from 5 minutes to 10 minutes the odds of contact fell 5 times.
The same study looked at the day of the week and the time of day. Those mattered too, but the authors wrote that the effect of response time "dwarfed them both".
What the study did not prove
Three cautions before you quote those multiples to your team.
- It was run with a company that sells lead-response software. That does not make it wrong, but it was not an independent, peer-reviewed paper.
- It measured phone calls to web leads in the industries that company served. Your market, your price point and your lead sources may behave differently.
- It measured contact and qualification, not closed deals. Reaching someone first gives you the first conversation. It does not win the deal for you.
A second piece by Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and Elkington in Harvard Business Review in March 2011 reached the same broad conclusion in its own words: "most companies are not responding nearly fast enough."
How slow most businesses really are
In 2014 InsideSales.com tested this from the customer's side by sending a web lead to thousands of companies and recording what came back. Of the 9,538 companies that received a lead, 2,142 called back at least once. That is 22%. Among those that did call, 779 called once and never again, and the first reply from most companies was an email, not a call. In the report's chart of first call times, 121 companies called within five minutes.
Put those together and the opportunity is plain. If the people who contact you also contact two or three of your competitors, the odds are good that none of them will call in the first five minutes. Being the one who does is a matter of process, and it costs nothing in advertising.
Why five minutes is hard for a small team
- The lead lands in an inbox nobody is watching. A form that only sends an email is as fast as the next time someone checks email.
- Nobody owns it. When a lead goes to "the team", each person assumes another one has it.
- People are on other calls, driving or showing a property.
- Leads arrive at night. People fill in forms after work.
- The first call feels unprepared, so it gets put off until there is time to "do it properly".
A five-minute plan that works with two or three people
- Send every form to one place that shows new leads at the top with the time they arrived. If you run more than one website or ad source, they should all land in the same list.
- Give each lead one owner the moment it arrives. Rotate between people if you have more than one. A lead with a name on it gets called. See how a small team shares follow-up.
- Alert a phone, not just an inbox. The alert should say who the lead is and how they came in, and it should repeat if nobody has acted.
- Write the first 20 seconds down. "Hi, this is Sam from [business]. You just asked about [what the form said]. Is now a good time for two questions?" A script this short removes the urge to prepare.
- Decide what happens when nobody can call. Name a backup person for each shift. For nights, decide when the first call is made the next morning and who makes it.
- Plan the second and third attempt. One call is not follow-up. Our follow-up schedule sets out the days and what to say on each.
- Measure it weekly. For each new lead record when it arrived and when the first call or text went out. Look at the middle value, not the average, because one lead that sat all weekend will distort an average.
Fast, but inside the rules
A form does not give you unlimited permission. In the United States the federal telemarketing rules limit calls to numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry, set calling hours, and require consent for marketing texts. A person who asks you a question has opened a short window for a reply about that question, but you still need to honor any request to stop, and a text needs its own consent. Before you automate anything, read what counts as consent to text a lead and the cold calling rules. This guide is general information, not legal advice.
How this fits in NuVentrec today
In NuVentrec a lead from a form lands in one list with its arrival time, goes to an owner by the routing rule you set, and shows as waiting until someone calls or texts. Call buttons are blocked for anyone on your opt-out list. The lost leads calculator gives a rough figure for what slow replies cost, and the what's live page lists the features that are switched on now.
Questions people ask
Is an instant automatic text enough?
It tells the person their form arrived, which helps, but only if they agreed to receive texts. It is not a conversation. The studies above measured a person reaching a person by phone. Use an automatic reply to buy a few minutes, not to replace the call.
What if the lead comes in at 11 at night?
Do not call. Federal rules bar telemarketing calls before 8 a.m. and after 9 p.m. in the person's local time, and a late call makes a poor first impression anyway. Send the email confirmation, and make that lead the first call of the next morning.
How many times should I try?
More than once. In the 2014 test about a third of the companies that called at all called a single time. Spread several attempts over the first days, vary the time of day, and stop when the person asks you to.
Does the best time of day matter?
The Lead Response Management study found late afternoon and early morning were better for reaching people than the hour before lunch. It also found that response time mattered far more. Call when the lead arrives, and use the better hours for second attempts.
Sources
- InsideSales.com and James Oldroyd, "Lead Response Management" study summary (copy of the study page dated July 17, 2008): definitions, response time by hour and by five-minute segment
- InsideSales.com, "Annual 2014 Lead Response Report": 9,538 companies, share that responded by phone, number of attempts, first response by email or phone
- James B. Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington, "The Short Life of Online Sales Leads", Harvard Business Review, March 2011
- 47 CFR 64.1200, "Delivery restrictions", paragraph (c)(1) (calling hours) and (c)(2) (Do Not Call Registry), Legal Information Institute