NuVentrec

Guides / Old leads

Guide · Lead follow-up

What to do with old leads: a plan that respects opt-outs

Most small businesses are sitting on a list of people who asked a question months or years ago and never heard back. Some of them are still worth a call. Before you work that list, sort it: who you may call, who you may only email or mail, and who you must leave alone.

By the NuVentrec team · Published October 12, 2026 · Updated October 23, 2026 · Sources last checked October 23, 2026 · General information, not legal advice

The short answer

  • Remove everyone who asked you to stop. A do-not-call request to your business has to be honored for 5 years, and it ends any "existing customer" exception.
  • An old inquiry does not keep a phone number open forever. Under the federal rules, an inquiry supports calls for three months (90 days under the FTC rule) and a purchase or transaction for 18 months (540 days under the FTC rule); use the shorter. After that, a number on the National Do Not Call Registry needs the person's permission.
  • Texts need their own consent, and an old form rarely gave it.
  • Email and postal mail are the gentlest way back in. Email has its own rules: say who you are, give a postal address and a working way to opt out.
  • Work the list in small batches with a next step for every reply, or you will create the same pile again.

Step 1: Sort the list into four piles

  1. Said stop. Anyone who told you not to call, text or email. They come off every outreach list, whatever else is true about them.
  2. Recent. Asked something in the last three months, or did business with you in the last 18.
  3. Old, with permission on file. You can show a form or a note where they agreed to be contacted, and what they agreed to.
  4. Old, with nothing on file. A name and a number from long ago.

If your records cannot tell these apart, that is the first thing to fix. Our guide on which records to keep lists what to save for each lead from now on.

Step 2: Take out the people who said stop

The Federal Communications Commission's rule, 47 CFR 64.1200(d), says a do-not-call request made to a business "must be honored for 5 years from the time the request is made". The same rule's definition of an established business relationship adds that such a request "terminates an established business relationship for purposes of telemarketing and telephone solicitation", and that this holds "even if the subscriber continues to do business with the seller". In other words, a past customer who said stop is still a stop.

Do this step against one list for the whole business, not each person's memory. See how to keep an opt-out list.

Step 3: Know how long an old inquiry lasts

The federal rule bars "telephone solicitations" to a residential subscriber whose number is on the National Do Not Call Registry. It defines a telephone solicitation as a call or message "for the purpose of encouraging the purchase or rental of, or investment in, property, goods, or services", and it carves out calls to a person "with that person's prior express invitation or permission" and to a person "with whom the caller has an established business relationship".

That relationship has a clock. It is formed by a purchase or transaction "within the eighteen (18) months immediately preceding the date of the telephone call", or by an inquiry or application "within the three months immediately preceding the date of the call". So:

  • A lead who filled in your form six weeks ago is inside the inquiry window.
  • A lead who asked a question last year, and never did business with you, is outside it. If the number is on the Registry, you need their permission before a sales call.
  • Anyone calling against the Registry must use a copy obtained "no more than 31 days prior to the date any call is made".

Two cautions. First, some states set shorter windows and stricter lists than the federal rule; cold calling rules covers the state side. Second, if your call is an offer to buy someone's property rather than to sell them something, whether it counts as a "telephone solicitation" is a question for your attorney. Until you have an answer, treat the list as if the rule applies.

Step 4: Do not assume you can text

Marketing texts sent with an autodialer need the person's prior express written consent under the same federal rule, and the wireless industry's own guidelines expect written agreement before promotional texts. A form from two years ago that only asked for "phone" did not collect that. Unless the record shows what the person agreed to, leave texting out of a reactivation plan. The details are in what counts as consent to text a lead.

Step 5: Start with email or mail

For the "old, nothing on file" pile, email and postal mail are the careful way to ask whether someone is still interested. Marketing email in the United States is governed by the CAN-SPAM Act. The Federal Trade Commission's guide lists what every commercial message needs, including:

  • "Don't use false or misleading header information" and "Don't use deceptive subject lines";
  • "Tell recipients where you're located", with a valid physical postal address;
  • "Tell recipients how to opt out of receiving future marketing email from you";
  • "Honor opt-out requests promptly": the opt-out must work for at least 30 days after sending, and you have 10 business days to act on a request.

The same guide notes that each email in violation can carry a penalty of up to $53,088. A short, honest note does best: who you are, why you are writing, one question, and an easy way to say no. Our guide to email rules for lead follow-up has example wording. A reply or a returned form is fresh permission, and you should save it with its date.

Step 6: Work it in small batches

  1. Pick 25 to 50 people from one pile.
  2. Reach out once by the channel that pile allows.
  3. For every reply, set an owner and a next step with a date the same day.
  4. For every "no" or "stop", add them to the opt-out list the same day.
  5. After two honest tries with no answer, mark the lead closed with a reason and move on.

Small batches matter because the point of the exercise is conversations you can actually have. Fifty replies you cannot answer this week are fifty new stale leads. A simple rhythm for the ones who do answer is in a follow-up schedule for a new seller lead.

What to write down as you go

  • The date and channel of each attempt.
  • Any reply, in the person's words.
  • New permission: what they agreed to, how, and when.
  • Every opt-out, with the date.
  • The reason a lead was closed.

How this fits in NuVentrec today

In NuVentrec you can filter contacts by how long it has been since the last contact, keep cold leads in their own pool away from the working list, and add a batch of people to a follow-up sequence that creates tasks for a person rather than sending anything by itself. Each account has one permanent opt-out list that blocks the call and text buttons for that person. The lost leads calculator gives a rough idea of what an unworked list is costing you, and the current list of features is on the what's live page.

Questions people ask

How old is too old to contact?

There is no age at which a lead becomes worthless, but there are dates at which the rules change: 90 days after an inquiry and 540 days after a transaction (the shorter FTC periods) for calls to numbers on the Do Not Call Registry. After those, start with email or mail and ask.

They opted out years ago. Can I ask if they changed their mind?

Not by the channel they opted out of. A do-not-call request to your business lasts 5 years under the federal rule, and an email opt-out does not expire. If they contact you first, that is a new conversation: record it.

I bought a list of old leads from someone else. Is that the same?

No. Their inquiry was not made to you, so you have no relationship with those people and no permission from them. Treat a bought list as cold, check it against the Do Not Call Registry and your own opt-out list, and do not text it.

Is one "are you still interested?" text really a problem?

It can be. The consent rules apply to the first message as much as the fiftieth. If you cannot show that the person agreed to texts from your business, do not send it.

Should I delete leads that never answer?

Close them with a reason and keep the opt-out and consent records. Keeping only what you need is good practice, but the record that someone said stop is one you need.

Sources

  1. 47 CFR 64.1200, "Delivery restrictions", paragraphs (c)(2), (d)(6), (f)(5) and (f)(15) (Do Not Call Registry, 5 years, established business relationship, telephone solicitation), Legal Information Institute
  2. Federal Trade Commission, "CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business" (seven main requirements, penalties)
  3. CTIA, "Messaging Principles and Best Practices" (May 2023), section 5.1 (consent for promotional texts)
  4. Federal Trade Commission, "Complying with the Telemarketing Sales Rule" (entity-specific Do Not Call)
  5. 16 CFR 310.2, Definitions ("established business relationship": 540 and 90 days), eCFR

Sort old leads by last contact and keep one opt-out list for all of them.

Try the interactive demoBook a walkthrough
Call now